What Is an HMRC Tax Investigation?
HMRC calls it a compliance check, its formal term for checking whether a return or a tax position is correct. A check can cover income tax, corporation tax, VAT or PAYE, and it usually starts with a letter rather than a visit. An investigation is not an accusation. HMRC checks returns for many reasons, including routine risk checks and random selection, and many end with HMRC accepting the figures as filed.
The opening letter sets the scope. It names the return and tax year under review, lists the items HMRC wants to look at, and gives a deadline, usually 30 days.
The Three Types of HMRC Enquiry
The type decides how serious the matter is and how long it runs. The opening letter normally shows which one you are dealing with.
Aspect enquiry
An aspect enquiry looks at one item in your return, such as a single expense claim or a relief you claimed. It is the most common type for small businesses and the quickest to resolve. If your records for that item are in order, it can close within a few months. Professional fees typically run from £1,000 to £3,000.
Full enquiry
A full enquiry examines the whole return and the records behind it. For self assessment returns HMRC opens it under section 9A of the Taxes Management Act 1970, and for company returns under Schedule 18 of the Finance Act 1998. Full enquiries often take 12 to 24 months, and fees usually run from £5,000 to £10,000.
Code of Practice 9 investigation
Code of Practice 9, known as COP9, is HMRC’s most serious civil procedure, used where HMRC suspects fraud. It offers a deal: full disclosure in exchange for HMRC not pursuing a criminal prosecution. If you receive a COP9 letter, you have 60 days to decide whether to accept. Do not handle this alone. Specialist advice is essential from day one.
What Triggers an HMRC Investigation?
HMRC rarely picks names out of a hat, though random selection does happen. Most enquiries start because data points to a risk. HMRC runs a data matching system called Connect, which gathers information from banks, the Land Registry, Companies House, the DVLA, online marketplaces and tax authorities overseas, then compares it with what you declared.
Common triggers are figures out of line with the sector, income HMRC can already see but which is missing from your return, a pattern of late filing, large or unusual claims, and a sharp drop in declared income. None of these proves an error, but each one gives HMRC a reason to look closer.
How Far Back Can HMRC Go?
For a return filed on time, HMRC generally has 12 months from the date it received the return to open an enquiry. For a company in a group that is not small, the 12 months run from the statutory filing date. If the return was filed late, the window runs to the next quarter day after the first anniversary of filing: 31 January, 30 April, 31 July or 31 October. Once the window has closed, HMRC can still raise a discovery assessment for earlier years, but only within fixed limits.
| Situation | How far back HMRC can go |
|---|---|
| Innocent error, reasonable care taken | 4 years |
| Careless error | 6 years |
| Deliberate error or concealment | 20 years |
What Penalties Could You Face?
If an enquiry finds unpaid tax, HMRC charges the tax, plus interest, plus a penalty based on your behaviour. The penalty depends on whether the error was careless, deliberate, or deliberate and concealed, and on whether you told HMRC yourself before or after it started asking.
| Behaviour | Unprompted disclosure | Prompted disclosure |
|---|---|---|
| Careless | 0% to 30% | 15% to 30% |
| Deliberate | 20% to 70% | 35% to 70% |
| Deliberate and concealed | 30% to 100% | 50% to 100% |
A penalty of 0% is possible when you took reasonable care, and an unprompted disclosure can cut a careless penalty to nothing, so tell HMRC about a mistake before it finds the problem. Ignoring a formal information notice is a separate risk: under Schedule 36 of the Finance Act 2008, HMRC can charge £300 for failing to comply, then up to £60 a day until you comply.
The Letter Has Arrived: What to Do in the First 48 Hours
The first two days set the tone. Work through these steps in order.
1. Do not panic, and do not ignore the letter. Put the deadline, usually 30 days, in your diary straight away. 2. Work out the scope. Which return, which tax year, and which items has HMRC asked about? Note the answers before you speak to anyone. 3. Call your accountant the same day, or find a tax adviser who handles HMRC enquiries. For guidance, see our guide on whether your small business needs an accountant. An adviser can take over correspondence, usually by filing a 64-8 authorisation form so HMRC deals with them directly. 4. Do not phone HMRC unprepared. Every conversation is on the record, so ask for questions in writing and answer in writing. 5. Gather your records, but send nothing until your adviser has reviewed them. 6. Check your own figures first. If your review turns up an error, tell HMRC with the corrected figures.
Mistakes That Make Things Worse
Replying without advice is the biggest error: HMRC correspondence uses precise technical language, and a casual answer can concede a point you did not mean to concede. Sending raw bank statements without reconciling them is another, since unexplained deposits are treated as income until you prove otherwise.
Answer exactly what HMRC asked, no more, and never volunteer information outside the scope. Missing a deadline invites escalation, so ask the officer for more time in writing rather than going quiet. Never alter or backdate a record: altered evidence turns a careless error into a deliberate one, with a penalty of up to 100% and a 20-year assessment window.
How Much Does an Investigation Cost?
Even when no extra tax is due, an investigation costs money, because you pay for the professional help to deal with it. A straightforward aspect enquiry typically costs £1,000 to £3,000 in accountancy fees. A full enquiry into a company usually costs £5,000 to £10,000. The Association of Taxation Technicians put the average enquiry defence cost at £4,929 in its 2024 professional fees survey.
Tax investigation insurance, also called fee protection insurance, covers those fees. Premiums for a sole trader usually run from about £40 to £150 a year, and for a small limited company from about £75 to £300 a year. Policies commonly cover £10,000 to £100,000 of fees per claim.
How to Reduce the Risk of an Enquiry
You cannot remove the risk entirely, since HMRC selects some returns at random, but good records make an enquiry less likely and cheaper. Sole traders must keep records for five years after the 31 January filing deadline, and companies for six years from the end of the financial year. Reconcile bank statements monthly, keep business and private spending separate, and file every return on time.
Making Tax Digital compatible software helps too, cutting transcription errors and leaving a clean digital trail. If you spot an error in a return you have already filed, correct it through the Digital Disclosure Service or an amended return. An error you disclose yourself can cost nothing, while the same error found by HMRC can cost up to 30% of the tax even when it was only careless. For more on records that stand up to scrutiny, read our small business bookkeeping guide.
What Happens at the End?
An enquiry ends with a closure notice stating HMRC’s conclusions and any extra tax due. Any tax found must normally be paid within 30 days, with interest from the original due date. If you disagree, you usually have 30 days to appeal to the First-tier Tribunal.
If the final bill is more than you can pay at once, do not miss the payment date. HMRC offers Time to Pay arrangements that spread the amount over monthly instalments, and our guide to HMRC Time to Pay arrangements explains how to apply.
Final Word
An HMRC tax investigation feels personal, but it is a process, and processes can be managed. The owners who come out best respond on time, answer only what was asked, keep clean records, and get professional help before they reply. An error admitted early can cost nothing. The same error discovered late can cost a penalty of up to 100% of the tax, plus interest.
Related reading
VAT Registration Threshold UK: £90,000 Guide (2026)
Corporation Tax Rates UK 2026/27: Worked Examples